Researching Mind

Essay

Scales Matter

A mind, a curvature and a napkin

This article was born from a real scene. Breakfast at a restaurant: our daughter Carolina, Jess and me, sitting at the table. The question was for me: “Dad, they told me about Einstein and the theory of relativity. Can you explain it to me?”

And I, with the little physics I know, thought: this is my moment. I had at hand everything a restaurant table offers: a napkin, the cutlery, whatever was lying around. I stretched the napkin, put something heavy in the middle, and it sank. With almost every adult, that example works; I have used it many times and they nod. Carolina looked at me with suspicion and, I think, not much wonder. Jess is an accomplished veterinarian, used to taking clinical histories, the kind you build out of questions that really matter. She looked at me the way you look at a cocker spaniel doing a trick and said: “Okay. And where is time?”

Where is time? I looked for it everywhere, even under the chairs, and it was nowhere on the napkin. You just can’t draw it that way. I understood that later.

What I learned, in plain words, is this: for Einstein, gravity is not an invisible rope pulling things. Mass bends space and time together, and things simply move along that bend. What my head built with the napkin was half of it: space.

I forgot about time, which is what we forget most. In everyday life we are short of the whole day; it is the deus ex machina of our irresponsibility. “I just ran out of time”: the most universal of all laws, the human way of explaining what an ordinary mind like mine cannot explain. Psychologists even have a name for part of it: Buehler, Griffin and Ross studied it as the planning fallacy, our habit of predicting we will finish sooner than we do. But what kept going round in my head was something else: why my head, with all the goodwill in the world, built exactly the half it understood and left out the half it didn’t. This article is my attempt to answer that, from psychology, which is what I study.

Scales matter

Scales really matter. They matter a lot, and the mind understands best what comes in its own size. Plenty of us like to talk about the laws of the universe (I do it myself a couple of times in this article), but how much do we really understand them? Honestly: in my case, very little. It is a scale that overwhelms me, and the little I understand, I like to use. I don’t deny my human nature.

We know space much better than we think: we measure it, and we even have two big ways of doing it, the metric system and feet and inches. But do we really understand it? A simple example. In The High Chaparral, or so I remember it from the Spanish dub I used to watch, when someone asked how far the land went, the answer was: as far as your eyes can see. And even with the measurements in hand, did anyone grasp the size of that? We just tell ourselves: “well, that must be a lot.”

Lucky for us, we don’t need exactness to live. We get by with phrases nobody argues with: time goes fast, slow or normal; this is big, small or medium. They are not exact measures, they are reasonable ones, and they work in almost every everyday situation. As a psychology student, I don’t know whether the brain is constantly after exactness. Some people live by it, with formulas and measurements, and for them the answer may be yes. But day to day, what we understand is what is usual, what we can anchor to what we have already lived. That is why “that must be a lot” is enough for a whole ranch, and “I ran out of time” is enough for almost everything else.

And what is a psychology student doing talking about spacetime? I like it, that simple. I understand little of it, as I already confessed, and that is exactly why it is useful to me. Trying to explain something I sometimes can’t even picture is my honest exercise: seeing which tools I reach for, where they break, and what that says about the head using them. So, fair warning: this is not a physics article. It is about what a mind does when something is too big for it.

Now, a curvature

Before the napkin, an explanation that is well worth it. For a long time, space and time lived apart. Space was the stage: length, width and height, still, the same for everyone. Time was a huge clock hanging somewhere in the universe, showing the same hour for everybody. That is how Newton thought of it, and that is how we think of it every time we arrange to meet someone.

With Einstein, the two ended up together. In plain words, it is less strange than it sounds. Think about how you arrange to meet someone: “on the corner of such-and-such, third floor, at eight.” Three pieces of data for the place and one for the hour. Without the hour, the meeting is useless: you arrive at the right corner on the wrong Tuesday. The universe works the same way. Everything that happens, happens in a place and at a moment, and those four pieces of data can’t be pulled apart. We call that package spacetime.

The second thing gives this section its name: mass bends that package. Not just the place, time too. And what does bending time mean? Something far less poetic than it sounds: clocks don’t run the same everywhere. Close to a big mass, like the Earth, they run a tiny bit slower; farther away, a tiny bit faster. A truly tiny bit: not something you will notice on the kitchen clock.

But some things do notice. How many times have we said “wow, time flies” without knowing that, up there, it literally does. The clocks on GPS satellites run ahead of the ones on the ground by about 38 millionths of a second a day (altitude speeds them up and velocity slows them down a little; that figure is what is left once you add the two), and they have to be corrected so your phone doesn’t send you to the wrong neighbourhood. Without knowing it, we said something literally true. We all carry a little Einstein in our ear rushing us along; us, with hours of procrastination, against his millionths.

The napkin, seriously

I take a napkin and stretch it tight between my hands. That taut surface stands for space. If I put nothing on it, it stays flat, and a little ball rolling across it goes in a straight line. That is space far from any mass.

Now I put something heavy in the middle. The napkin sinks. If I roll the ball close to the dip, it no longer goes straight: it veers, circles the hollow, sometimes falls in. Nobody pushed it. It followed the straightest path that surface allowed. That is the image we all use for Einstein’s idea: mass doesn’t pull on things, it bends the place they move through. Bertrand Russell explained it to the general public in 1925, in a chapter bluntly titled “The Abolition of ‘Force’”.

Up to there, the napkin works. But let’s take an inventory of what is on it. The cloth is a surface, the dip is a shape and the ball travels distances. Everything it shows is space. And there is one more detail: the ball rolls to the centre because the Earth pulls it down. To explain gravity, the example uses gravity. Real space, besides, has no “down” to sink into.

And so we arrive at Jess’s question, except now we know why the napkin couldn’t answer it: if the theory talks about spacetime, and the napkin only has space, time was left out.

The uncomfortable answer is that time is not a detail missing from the drawing. For slow things, like an apple or a planet, it is almost everything. We already saw it with the GPS clocks: they don’t run the same close to the mass as far from it. In my own words: slow things “fall” towards where clocks run slower, and that effect is enough to get Newton’s gravity back, the apple’s gravity. What the napkin can’t show is exactly what makes the apple fall.

A mind: why I get stuck

This is where what I study, or what I want to study, comes in. In the previous essay, “The Brain That Predicts”, I said that computational psychology writes the answer down as a model you can run. Battaglia, Hamrick and Tenenbaum did that with everyday physics: in 2013 they proposed that we carry in our heads something like the physics engine of a video game (the comparison is theirs), a fast, approximate simulator, good for telling whether a stack of dishes is going to topple, and they tested it against what people answer. That engine simulates in time, because a fall happens in time. What follows is my reading, and I mark it as mine: its clock is fixed, Newton’s, the huge clock hanging in the universe, and it runs the same for everything. That is why the napkin convinces: it bends space and leaves time outside, ticking on the usual clock. And that is why I get stuck when someone asks where time is: my engine never had a time that could bend. The irony has its charm: Newton’s clock won’t let me see that Newton’s apple falls because of time.

It isn’t laziness, it is economics. In that same essay I said the brain pays two bills: one for energy, because it is very expensive, and one for surprise, for everything it failed to anticipate. Lieder and Griffiths propose something related, a rational use of limited resources: the mind doesn’t look for the perfect answer, it looks for the best one it can afford with what it has. In plain words: my head was never going to pay for a clock that bends if Newton’s was enough to save the dishes.

And the napkin is a bargain on both bills. It is cheap to imagine and surprises no one: things that weigh, cloth that sinks, little balls that roll down. We have known all of that our whole lives. My reading, mine again, is that when something doesn’t surprise us, we feel we understood it. That is why almost everyone nods at the napkin, and why the question about time arrives late. Kahneman and Klein studied this in another field: intuition deserves trust when it was formed in a regular environment, with practice and with feedback. Ours was formed among falling cups and paths walked on foot. Not in spacetime.

What lies between the two

I am not trying to give a physics lesson. If I had wanted to, the napkin would be a bad teacher: it explains space and hides time, which is the part that matters. But it is the most human example I found. When something is too big for us, we grab what is close: a cloth, a little ball, a “that must be a lot.” It isn’t cheating; it is what is at hand. The napkin didn’t give me the answer. It gave me the question, and the question brought me here, with a stack of dishes and a clock that doesn’t bend. The napkin is made at our scale; spacetime is not. What lies between the two is what I still have to learn.

Translated from the Spanish original.

Sources

  1. Ashby, N. (2003). Relativity in the Global Positioning System. Living Reviews in Relativity, 6, 1. https://doi.org/10.12942/lrr-2003-1
  2. Battaglia, P. W., Hamrick, J. B., & Tenenbaum, J. B. (2013). Simulation as an engine of physical scene understanding. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 110(45), 18327–18332. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1306572110
  3. Buehler, R., Griffin, D., & Ross, M. (1994). Exploring the "planning fallacy": Why people underestimate their task completion times. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 67(3), 366–381. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.67.3.366
  4. Carroll, S. M. (1997). Lecture notes on general relativity [Lecture notes] (ch. 4, eqs. 4.21–4.24). arXiv:gr-qc/9712019v1. https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.gr-qc/9712019
  5. Kahneman, D., & Klein, G. (2009). Conditions for intuitive expertise: A failure to disagree. American Psychologist, 64(6), 515–526. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0016755
  6. Lieder, F., & Griffiths, T. L. (2020). Resource-rational analysis: Understanding human cognition as the optimal use of limited computational resources. Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 43, e1 (published online 2019). https://doi.org/10.1017/S0140525X1900061X
  7. Ravello Joo, C. E. (2026). El cerebro que predice. Researching Mind. https://researchingmind.com/pensamientos/el-cerebro-paga-dos-facturas-es
  8. Russell, B. (1925). The ABC of relativity. Harper & Brothers. Ch. XIII, «The abolition of "force"». https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/67104

Every claim in this essay was read at its source on 11 November 2026; the verification file records the source, the original wording and how it was checked. The 38 millionths are my own arithmetic on the factor Ashby gives (eq. 35). Carroll is cited by equation number: the printed page is still pending. What is marked as my reading is the author’s inference. The High Chaparral line is a memory, not a quotation.

  • Cognitive psychology
  • Computational psychology
  • Bounded rationality
  • Intuitive physics
  • Spacetime

← All essays